Second opinion

A Second Opinion on Cervical Spine (Neck) Surgery

If you have been told you need surgery on your neck, it is reasonable to want a second opinion before you decide. I am glad to provide one, and I can generally see you personally within 1-2 weeks.

Why get a second opinion?

Two experienced surgeons can look at the same patient and the same MRI and recommend different approaches. Depending on the source of your symptoms, the options may include an ACDF, a cervical disc replacement, a posterior cervical fusion, a laminoplasty, a laminectomy/foraminotomy, or no surgery at all. Surgeons can reasonably differ on which of these is best for a given patient.

A second opinion is common, and it is not a vote of no confidence in your surgeon. Most surgeons welcome one. My experience is that patients who feel well-informed about their surgical decision are generally more satisfied with the results.

What do you look for when you review a recommendation for surgery?

I start with you, not the MRI. MRIs are not perfect! Many adults have disc bulges and arthritis on their scans that cause no symptoms at all. It is your history and exam that provide context for your MRI and help determine whether a finding on imaging is the cause of your pain. In particular, I consider:

  • Do your symptoms match what is seen on your imaging?
  • Have non-surgical treatments, such as physical therapy, medications, and injections, been given a fair trial?
  • Have you had the appropriate type of injection for your problem?
  • Is there weakness, numbness, or other signs or symptoms of spinal cord compression (myelopathy) that make surgery more pressing?
  • Is the proposed operation the least invasive option that addresses the source of your symptoms?
  • Is the number of spinal levels included in the surgery appropriate?
  • Would you be a candidate for a disc replacement rather than a fusion, or vice versa?
What might the outcome of a second opinion be?

There are a few possibilities:

  • I agree with the recommendation you have already received. Many patients find that reassuring, and they proceed with more confidence.
  • I suggest a different operation, such as a disc replacement instead of a fusion, a different approach, or fewer spinal levels.
  • I recommend more non-surgical treatment first.
  • I may not recommend any surgery at all. If your pain is due to the muscles and soft tissues around your spine, for example, surgery is unlikely to help.

Whatever I find, I will explain my reasoning, including the advantages and disadvantages of each option. You are welcome to have your surgery wherever you feel most comfortable.

I've already had neck surgery. Can you review it?

Yes. I commonly review previous cervical spine surgeries that were performed elsewhere, including for patients with persistent or new symptoms, a fusion that has not healed (pseudoarthrosis), or degeneration next to a prior fusion. You can read more on my page about cervical spine revision surgery.

Please note that I do not provide immediate post-operative care for patients whose surgery was performed by another surgeon. In the weeks after surgery, your own surgeon is the right person to call with questions or concerns.

What should I bring to my appointment?

The more I can see, the more useful my opinion will be. Please bring or send:

  • Your imaging - the images themselves, not only the reports. This includes your MRI and any CT scans or X-rays, particularly flexion-extension X-rays (taken while bending the neck forward and back). My staff will help coordinate uploading your images in advance of your visit or requesting them from the facilities where they were obtained. On occasion, we may ask you to bring a disc with you to the appointment.
  • The notes from the surgeon who recommended surgery, if you have them, including the specific operation proposed.
  • A list of the treatments you have tried (e.g. physical therapy, medications, injections, ablations) and which ones helped.
  • Any nerve testing (EMG) results.
  • Operative reports from any previous spine surgery.
What questions should I ask my surgeon about neck surgery?

Whether you meet with me or another surgeon, these questions are worth asking:

  • What is the source of my pain, and how confident are you?
  • What is likely to happen if I wait?
  • Why this operation, rather than the alternatives?
  • Why this number of spinal levels?
  • Am I a candidate for a disc replacement? Why or why not?
  • What are the risks, and what does recovery look like?
  • Which of my symptoms is surgery most likely to improve, and which may not change?
Will my insurance cover a second opinion?

Insurance plans generally cover a second opinion the same way as any other specialist visit. I accept most major commercial insurance plans. Medicare and managed Medicare are not accepted for spine care, and I do not accept Medicaid or Tricare. HMO plans require a referral from your primary care physician.

Should I meet with you?

If you live near Denver and have been told you need neck surgery, or you are still weighing your options, please consider meeting me in consultation for a second opinion. If another surgeon has recommended surgery, I can generally see you personally within 1-2 weeks to review the proposed procedure and give you my opinion. Second opinion visits are expedited for patients with a pending surgery, so please let my office know if you already have a surgery date.

Request a visitCall