Why get a second opinion?
Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a safe, effective, and well-established therapy, but there are nuances in how it is used, and surgical volume and experience have a strong influence on patient outcomes. A recommendation for DBS is the first of several decisions, including which brain target to use, whether to treat one side of the brain or both, whether surgery is performed awake or asleep, which device to implant, and who will program it afterward. For patients with essential tremor, focused ultrasound is also worth discussing. Surgeons and centers can reasonably differ on these choices.
A second opinion is common, and it is not a vote of no confidence in your surgeon or your neurologist. My experience is that patients who feel well-informed about their surgical decision are generally more satisfied with the results.
What do you look for when you review a recommendation for DBS?
- Do I agree with your diagnosis?
- Is DBS likely to help the symptoms that bother you most? In Parkinson's disease, for example, DBS tends to help the symptoms that respond to levodopa, while balance and speech often improve less.
- Have the appropriate pre-operative tests been done? Neuropsychological testing is always recommended before DBS, and patients with Parkinson's disease also need a levodopa sensitivity challenge (a comparison of your symptoms with and without your medication).
- Is the proposed target, and treating one side or both, a good fit for your symptoms, overall physical and cognitive health, and goals?
- Is there a clear plan for programming your device after surgery?
What might the outcome of a second opinion be?
There are a few possibilities:
- I agree with the recommendation you have already received. Many patients find that reassuring, and they proceed with more confidence.
- I suggest a different target, a different approach to treating one or both sides, or a different technique.
- I suggest a different treatment, such as focused ultrasound for patients with essential tremor.
- I recommend additional testing or medication adjustments with your neurologist first.
- I suggest connecting you with one of my partnering movement disorder neurologists to take a deeper dive into your symptoms, diagnosis, and history, and to provide an expert resource for care (including DBS programming) going forward.
Whatever I find, I will explain my reasoning, including the advantages and disadvantages of each option.
How do you perform DBS?
I perform DBS with you asleep (general anesthesia). I use a surgical robot (Rosa) to assist with placement of the leads, and I verify accuracy with a CT and electrode recordings in the operating room. I use all three device vendors (Medtronic, Boston Scientific, and Abbott), and I will implant using the manufacturer you and your neurologist prefer. My DBS page and DBS patient guide describe the surgery and recovery in detail.
What should I bring to my appointment?
The more I can see, the more useful my opinion will be. Please bring or send:
- Your MRI - the images themselves, not only the report. My staff will help coordinate uploading your images in advance of your visit or requesting them from the facilities where they were obtained. On occasion, we may ask you to bring a disc with you to the appointment.
- The notes from your neurologist and from the surgeon who recommended DBS, including the proposed target, sides, and device, if you have them.
- The results of your levodopa sensitivity challenge and neuropsychological testing, if they have been done.
- A list of your current medications, with doses and times of day.
What questions should I ask my surgeon about DBS?
Whether you meet with me or another surgeon, these questions are worth asking:
- Which of my symptoms is DBS most likely to improve, and which may not change?
- Which brain target do you recommend for me, and why?
- Would you treat one side of the brain or both, and at the same time or in stages?
- Is the surgery performed awake or asleep?
- Which device would suit me, and who will program it?
- Which risks matter most in my situation?
- How many DBS surgeries do you perform each year?
Will my insurance cover a second opinion?
Insurance plans generally cover a second opinion the same way as any other specialist visit. I accept most major commercial insurance plans, and Medicare and managed Medicare are accepted for movement disorders. I do not accept Medicaid or Tricare. HMO plans require a referral from your primary care physician.
Should I meet with you?
If you live near Denver and have been recommended DBS for Parkinson's disease, essential tremor, or dystonia, please consider meeting me in consultation for a second opinion. Second opinion visits are expedited for patients with a pending surgery, so please let my office know if you already have a surgery date.