Why get a second opinion?
The landscape of epilepsy surgery has changed dramatically in recent years. There are nuances in both the evaluation and the choice of procedure, and experience has a strong influence on patient outcomes. Depending on where your seizures begin and whether that part of the brain is essential for normal function, the options may include removing or treating the epileptic tissue (resection or laser ablation) or neuromodulation with RNS (NeuroPace), DBS, or VNS. Sometimes a diagnostic surgery called SEEG is needed first to pinpoint where seizures start. Surgeons and epilepsy teams can reasonably differ on which of these is best for a given patient.
A second opinion is common, and it is not a vote of no confidence in your surgeon or your neurologist. Most surgeons welcome one. My experience is that patients who feel well-informed about their surgical decision are generally more satisfied with the results.
What do you look for when you review a recommendation for surgery?
My first goal in treating an epilepsy patient is understanding where in the brain the seizures are arising. In particular, I consider:
- Do I agree with your diagnosis, including whether your epilepsy is focal (starting in one part of the brain) or generalized (involving the whole brain)?
- Has the evaluation been complete? All patients should have had a video EEG and a brain MRI before surgery. In some cases, additional testing, such as a neuropsychological evaluation and a PET scan, among others, is also helpful.
- How confident are we about where your seizures begin, and is there more than one area involved? Would SEEG help answer that question?
- Is the epileptic tissue essential for speech, movement, vision, or memory?
- Is the proposed procedure the best balance between the chance of seizure control and the risk to normal function, given your goals?
- Is there a plan for coordinated care with an epilepsy neurologist after surgery, including medications and any device programming?
What might the outcome of a second opinion be?
There are a few possibilities:
- I agree with the recommendation you have already received. Many patients find that reassuring, and they proceed with more confidence.
- I recommend additional testing first, such as an EMU stay (video EEG monitoring in a hospital epilepsy monitoring unit), neuropsychological testing, or SEEG, to better understand where your seizures begin.
- I suggest a different procedure, such as neuromodulation rather than removing brain tissue, or vice versa.
- I suggest connecting you with one of my epilepsy neurology colleagues to take a deeper dive into your seizures, diagnosis, and history, and to provide an expert resource for care going forward.
Whatever I find, I will explain my reasoning, including the advantages and disadvantages of each option.
I was told surgery isn't an option because my epilepsy is generalized. Is that true?
Not necessarily. Because generalized epilepsy involves the whole brain, surgeries that remove or burn part of the brain are not appropriate. However, RNS placed in the thalamus can help many patients with idiopathic generalized epilepsy (IGE) whose seizures are not controlled with medications. This use of RNS is currently off-label, meaning it has not yet been approved by the FDA for generalized epilepsy. I have implanted RNS in patients with IGE for years.
How do you perform epilepsy surgery?
I am the director of functional neurosurgery at HCA HealthONE Swedish, a level 4 epilepsy center, and I work closely with epilepsy neurologists to evaluate and treat each patient. I use a surgical robot (Rosa) to place SEEG electrodes and RNS leads in a precise and minimally invasive manner. My guides to surgical options for epilepsy, SEEG, RNS, and resection describe these procedures in detail.
I've already had surgery for epilepsy. Can you review it?
Yes. Some patients continue to have seizures after a resection, laser ablation, or VNS, and there are often still options, such as RNS.
Please note that I do not provide immediate post-operative care for patients whose surgery was performed by another surgeon. In the weeks after surgery, your own surgeon is the right person to call with questions or concerns.
What should I bring to my appointment?
The more I can see, the more useful my opinion will be. My office can help coordinate and request records as needed. Please bring or send:
- Your MRI and any PET scans - the images themselves, not only the reports. My staff will help coordinate uploading your images in advance of your visit or requesting them from the facilities where they were obtained. On occasion, we may ask you to bring a disc with you to the appointment.
- Reports from your video EEG, neuropsychological testing, and any SEEG.
- The notes from your neurologist and from the surgeon who recommended surgery, including the specific procedure proposed.
- A list of the anti-seizure medications you have tried and the ones you take now.
- A seizure diary, if you keep one. It can also be very helpful to bring a family member who has witnessed one or more of your seizures.
What questions should I ask my surgeon about epilepsy surgery?
Whether you meet with me or another surgeon, these questions are worth asking:
- Is my epilepsy focal or generalized?
- Where do my seizures begin, and how confident are we?
- Do I need SEEG or other testing before deciding?
- What are the chances this procedure will make me seizure-free, or reduce my seizures?
- Are there risks to speech, memory, vision, or movement in my case?
- Who will manage my medications and any implanted device afterward?
- How many of these procedures do you perform each year?
Will my insurance cover a second opinion?
Insurance plans generally cover a second opinion the same way as any other specialist visit. I accept most major commercial insurance plans. Medicare and managed Medicare are not accepted for epilepsy care, and I do not accept Medicaid or Tricare. HMO plans require a referral from your primary care physician.
Should I meet with you?
If you live near Denver and have been recommended surgery for epilepsy, please consider meeting me in consultation for a second opinion. I prefer a referral from your neurologist, because it will include records of your epilepsy care. Second opinion visits are expedited for patients with a pending surgery, so please let my office know if you already have a surgery date.