Second opinion

A Second Opinion on Facial Pain Surgery

If you have been told you need surgery for trigeminal neuralgia or another facial pain disorder, it is reasonable to want a second opinion before you decide. I am glad to provide one.

Why get a second opinion?

Trigeminal neuralgia and other facial pain disorders are very treatable, but there are nuances in both diagnosis and treatment, and experience with these disorders has a strong influence on patient outcomes. The first-line surgical options for trigeminal neuralgia (TN) are microvascular decompression (MVD), radiosurgery (e.g. Gamma Knife), and trigeminal rhizotomy. I perform each of these. Each has advantages and disadvantages, including how quickly it works, how long the relief tends to last, and the risk of facial numbness. Deciding between them requires a thoughtful discussion, and surgeons can reasonably differ on which is best for a given patient. My patient guide to surgical options for TN compares these procedures in more detail.

Just as important, trigeminal neuralgia and other facial pain disorders are frequently misdiagnosed. They can be mistaken for dental or sinus problems, and for one another. Sometimes I might recommend an additional evaluation by a dentist, ENT, orofacial pain specialist, or neurologist. The right treatment depends on the right diagnosis.

A second opinion is common, and it is not a vote of no confidence in your surgeon. My experience is that patients who feel well-informed about their surgical decision are generally more satisfied with the results.

What do you look for when you review a recommendation for surgery?

I start with the diagnosis. Facial pain diagnoses are clinical, meaning they are based on your symptoms and a physical exam, not an X-ray or blood test. TN can be mistaken for similar disorders, such as glossopharyngeal neuralgia, sphenopalatine neuralgia, and trigeminal neuropathic pain, and these are treated differently. In particular, I consider:

  • Do I agree with your diagnosis?
  • Have you had a fair trial of medications, including at least one of carbamazepine (Tegretol) or oxcarbazepine (Trileptal)?
  • Has your MRI been performed with the right sequences? Have those sequences been interpreted correctly? There is nuance in reviewing these MRIs. The reports are sometimes misleading, and seeing a provider who is experienced matters.
  • Is the proposed procedure well suited to your age, health, pain pattern, and goals?
  • If you have had surgery before, what was done, how well did it work, and how have your symptoms changed since?
What might the outcome of a second opinion be?

There are a few possibilities:

  • I agree with the recommendation you have already received. Many patients find that reassuring, and they proceed with more confidence.
  • I suggest a different procedure, for example one that better fits your health, your pain pattern, or your priorities about numbness and durability of relief.
  • I recommend additional medication trials before surgery.
  • I find that your pain is due to a different disorder, which may call for a different treatment altogether.

Whatever I find, I will explain my reasoning, including the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

I've already had surgery for facial pain. Can you review it?

Yes. TN can be a lifelong condition, and symptoms can return even after years of relief. Some patients need more than one treatment over a lifetime. I commonly see patients whose pain has returned after an MVD, radiosurgery, or rhizotomy performed elsewhere, and there are usually still good options. You can read more on my trigeminal neuralgia page.

Please note that I do not provide immediate post-operative care for patients whose surgery was performed by another surgeon. In the weeks after surgery, your own surgeon is the right person to call with questions or concerns.

What should I bring to my appointment?

The more I can see, the more useful my opinion will be. Please bring or send:

  • Your MRI - the images themselves, not only the report. My staff will help coordinate uploading your images in advance of your visit or requesting them from the facilities where they were obtained. On occasion, we may ask you to bring a disc with you to the appointment.
  • The notes from the surgeon who recommended surgery, if you have them, including the specific procedure proposed.
  • A list of the medications you have tried, with the highest doses you reached, and whether they helped or caused side effects.
  • Operative reports from any previous facial pain procedures.
  • A record of your symptoms over a few weeks: where the pain is, what it feels like, what triggers it, and how often it comes.
What questions should I ask my surgeon about facial pain surgery?

Whether you meet with me or another surgeon, these questions are worth asking:

  • Is my pain classic trigeminal neuralgia, or something else?
  • Why this procedure, rather than the alternatives?
  • How likely is it to relieve my pain, and how long does relief usually last?
  • What is the risk of facial numbness?
  • What are the options if my pain returns?
  • How many of these procedures do you perform each year?
Will my insurance cover a second opinion?

Insurance plans generally cover a second opinion the same way as any other specialist visit. I accept most major commercial insurance plans. Medicare and managed Medicare are accepted for trigeminal neuralgia, but not for other facial pain disorders. I do not accept Medicaid or Tricare. HMO plans require a referral from your primary care physician.

Should I meet with you?

If you live near Denver and have been told you need surgery for trigeminal neuralgia or another facial pain disorder, please consider meeting me in consultation for a second opinion. Second opinion visits are expedited for patients with a pending surgery, so please let my office know if you already have a surgery date.

Request a visitCall