Second opinion

A Second Opinion on Brain Tumor Surgery

If you have been told you need surgery or radiation for a brain tumor, it is reasonable to want a second opinion before you decide. I am glad to provide one.

Why get a second opinion?

A new brain tumor diagnosis can be intimidating. There are nuances in deciding whether, when, and how to treat a brain tumor, and experience has a strong influence on patient outcomes. Depending on the tumor's type, size, and location, the options may include surgery (craniotomy), radiosurgery (e.g. Gamma Knife), other forms of radiation, medications, or simply monitoring with MRI scans. Certain tumors don't need to be treated at all! Surgeons can reasonably differ on which of these is best for a given patient.

A second opinion is common, and it is not a vote of no confidence in your surgeon. Most surgeons welcome one. My experience is that patients who feel well-informed about their surgical decision are generally more satisfied with the results.

What do you look for when you review a recommendation for surgery?

A specialist can provide context for an MRI finding, review prognosis and management options, and help select a course of action that aligns with your goals. In particular, I consider:

  • Do I agree with the likely diagnosis, based on your imaging and symptoms?
  • Does the tumor need treatment now, or can it be safely watched with MRI scans?
  • If treatment is needed, is surgery, radiosurgery, or another approach the best fit for the tumor's type, size, and location, and for your age, overall health, and goals?
  • If surgery is recommended, what are its goals? Examples include a biopsy to establish the diagnosis or removing as much of the tumor as can be safely removed.
  • Is the tumor near areas of the brain that control movement or speech, and would brain mapping help preserve function?
  • Is there a plan for coordinated care after surgery, including follow-up MRIs and any radiation or medications?
What might the outcome of a second opinion be?

There are a few possibilities:

  • I agree with the recommendation you have already received. Many patients find that reassuring, and they proceed with more confidence.
  • I suggest a different surgical approach, such as a smaller "keyhole" craniotomy, a different route to the tumor, or the use of brain mapping.
  • I suggest radiosurgery (e.g. Gamma Knife) instead of surgery, or surgery instead of radiation.
  • I recommend monitoring the tumor with MRI scans rather than treating it now.

Whatever I find, I will explain my reasoning, including the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

Will a second opinion delay my treatment?

It depends on when you request a second opinion and the urgency of your situation. Many tumors, such as small meningiomas, can be safely watched for months or years. Others, such as some gliomas and metastases, call for prompt treatment. If your surgeon has advised treatment soon, please notify my office of your surgical date so that we can fit you in as soon as possible.

How do you perform brain tumor surgery?

My philosophy is to use the smallest possible craniotomy to safely achieve the goals of surgery. I tend to use "keyhole" craniotomies, often about the size of a large coin, though the size depends on the location and nature of the tumor. I use 3D navigation, microscopy, fluorescence, and intraoperative ultrasound, and I commonly use motor and speech mapping to help preserve neurologic function. I shave only a short strip of hair along the incision. I also perform Gamma Knife radiosurgery. My craniotomy patient guide and Gamma Knife patient guide describe these treatments in detail.

I've already had treatment for a brain tumor. Can you review it?

Yes. I see patients whose tumors have grown or returned after surgery or radiation elsewhere, and I can review the options for further treatment.

Please note that I do not provide immediate post-operative care for patients whose surgery was performed by another surgeon. In the weeks after surgery, your own surgeon is the right person to call with questions or concerns.

What should I bring to my appointment?

The more I can see, the more useful my opinion will be. My office can help coordinate and request records as needed. Please bring or send:

  • Your MRIs - the images themselves, not only the reports. If you have had more than one MRI, the earlier scans are especially helpful, since they show whether the tumor is growing. My staff will help coordinate uploading your images in advance of your visit or requesting them from the facilities where they were obtained. On occasion, we may ask you to bring a disc with you to the appointment.
  • The notes from the surgeon who recommended treatment, if you have them, including the specific procedure proposed.
  • Pathology reports from any biopsy or previous surgery.
  • A list of your symptoms, including any seizures, and your current medications.
What questions should I ask my surgeon about brain tumor surgery?

Whether you meet with me or another surgeon, these questions are worth asking:

  • What type of tumor do you think this is, and how confident are you?
  • Does it need treatment now, or can it be watched?
  • What are the goals of surgery, and how much of the tumor can be safely removed?
  • Are there risks to movement, speech, vision, or memory in my case?
  • Would brain mapping help?
  • Are radiosurgery or monitoring reasonable alternatives for me?
  • How many of these surgeries do you perform each year?
Will my insurance cover a second opinion?

Insurance plans generally cover a second opinion the same way as any other specialist visit. I accept most major commercial insurance plans. Medicare and managed Medicare are not accepted for brain tumor care, and I do not accept Medicaid or Tricare. HMO plans require a referral from your primary care physician.

Should I meet with you?

If you live near Denver and have been told you need surgery or radiation for a brain tumor, please consider meeting me in consultation for a second opinion. Second opinion visits are expedited for patients with a pending surgery, so please let my office know if you already have a surgery date.

Request a visitCall